| Radiation protection and test evidence |
| Lead equivalence | Declared lead equivalence in mm Pb, together with the test report and the tube voltage and test method used. | Compare products only when the reported test conditions and measurement basis are comparable. | Confirm the value meets the project’s shielding design and applicable local requirements; do not compare mm Pb values without their test conditions. |
| Applicable test standard | Standard and edition cited in the product documentation. For translucent protective plates, ask whether testing was conducted to IEC 61331-2 and request the report. | Check that the standard applies to the product and that the report identifies the tested sample and configuration. | Require complete, traceable documentation rather than a certificate or marketing statement alone. |
| Test report traceability | Report number, test date, laboratory identity, sample description, measurement conditions, and results. | Verify that the report corresponds to the quoted glass type, thickness, size range, and construction. | Resolve any mismatch between the tested sample and the offered product before approval. |
| Protection across operating conditions | Test results or technical justification for the X-ray energy range and installation conditions specified for the project. | Assess the evidence against the facility’s actual equipment, workload, and shielding design—not a generic product description. | Have the responsible radiation-protection professional confirm suitability. |
| Optical performance and product quality |
| Visible light transmission | Measured visible-light transmission, test method, and whether the figure applies to the quoted thickness and glass construction. | Compare values measured using the same method and equivalent product configurations. | Check that visibility and room lighting needs are met; avoid treating figures from different methods as directly equivalent. |
| Optical clarity and distortion | Inspection criteria, tolerances, and documented checks for bubbles, inclusions, haze, scratches, and visual distortion. | Review written acceptance criteria and, where practical, inspect a production-representative sample. | Agree in writing on acceptable appearance and inspection conditions before production. |
| Dimensions and tolerances | Available panel sizes, thickness, dimensional tolerances, edge finishing, and permitted cut-outs or processing. | Compare the full finished-panel specification, not just nominal glass dimensions. | Confirm the product fits the frame and installation design without compromising the required shielding. |
| Quality management and batch control | Quality-system documentation, incoming-material checks, production inspection records, and batch or lot identification. | Assess whether the supplier can link delivered panels to production and inspection records. | Confirm how nonconforming product, replacement, and corrective action are handled. |
| Packaging and transport protection | Packaging method, handling instructions, damage reporting process, and responsibility for transit damage. | Compare protection for the panel’s size, weight, fragility, and shipping route. | Require a documented inspection and claims procedure at delivery. |
| Commercial terms and lifecycle cost |
| Quoted product cost | Price per panel, currency, quote validity, included processing, and any minimum order quantity. | Normalize quotes to the same dimensions, thickness, lead equivalence, finish, and order quantity. | Do not rank on unit price until scope and specification are aligned. |
| Installed and delivered cost | Packaging, freight, insurance, duties, taxes, installation requirements, and any site-specific charges. | Calculate the comparable delivered and installed cost for the same project scope. | Record exclusions and confirm who is responsible for installation and handling. |
| Lead time and delivery reliability | Quoted production lead time, shipping estimate, capacity assumptions, and process for schedule changes. | Compare the date the order can be accepted through the expected delivery date, including transit. | Ask for written confirmation of the schedule and notification of delays. |
| Warranty and remedies | Warranty period and scope, exclusions, claim process, and remedies for defects or damage. | Compare coverage and response commitments in the written terms, not informal assurances. | Confirm the warranty is compatible with the project’s installation and operating conditions. |
| Replacement and service support | Replacement availability, support contact, spare-panel lead time, and documentation provided after delivery. | Assess the practical time and cost required to restore the installation if a panel is damaged or rejected. | Prefer clearly documented support and replacement arrangements for critical installations. |
| Lifecycle cost | Initial product cost + delivery and installation + expected inspection and maintenance + expected replacement and downtime costs. | Use the same evaluation period, assumptions, and currency for every quote. Treat uncertain future costs as estimates, not guaranteed values. | Choose on documented compliance, quality, service, and total cost—not lowest purchase price alone. |
| Supplier comparison record |
| Supplier evaluation fields | Enter verified values from current quotations and supporting documents. Do not substitute unverified estimates. | Supplier A: Enter verified data Supplier B: Enter verified data Supplier C: Enter verified data | Record document references, quote dates, and any assumptions used in the comparison. |