| Relevant Mold Experience | 15% | Experience with the intended process, part geometry, material, mold size, and production volume. | Examples of comparable projects, anonymized part or mold images, and references where available. | Score higher when the supplier can demonstrate relevant, technically similar work. |
| Engineering and Design Capability | 15% | Ability to review part drawings, advise on draft and wall thickness, and design forming, trimming, cooling, and venting features. | Design review workflow, sample design-for-manufacturing feedback, and 3D mold drawings for approval. | Score higher for documented design reviews and clear approval checkpoints before machining. |
| Material and Tooling Specification | 12% | Suitability of the specified mold material, construction, surface finish, and any coatings for the application. | Material grade and supplier documentation, mold drawings, surface-finish requirements, and maintenance recommendations. | Score higher when specifications are explicit, traceable, and matched to the intended process and service conditions. |
| Manufacturing and Inspection Capability | 15% | Availability of suitable machining, finishing, assembly, and dimensional inspection for the mold’s requirements. | Process plan, inspection equipment list, sample inspection report, and critical-dimension measurement method. | Score higher when inspection methods and acceptance criteria are agreed before production. |
| Prototype, Sampling, and Acceptance Process | 12% | How the supplier conducts mold trials, evaluates formed parts, records issues, and manages corrective actions. | Trial plan, sample-part inspection results, defect records, and a written mold acceptance checklist. | Score higher for a defined sampling process with measurable acceptance criteria and documented corrective actions. |
| Quality Management and Traceability | 10% | Control of drawings, revisions, production records, nonconforming work, and final inspection. | Quality procedures, sample inspection records, document-control practices, and any relevant third-party certificates for verification. | Score higher when records are consistent, traceable, and available for the specific order. |
| Communication and Project Management | 8% | Clarity and consistency in technical communication, milestone reporting, and management of design changes. | Project schedule, named technical contact, meeting or reporting cadence, and change-control process. | Score higher for prompt, specific responses and documented ownership of project milestones. |
| Lead Time and Delivery Planning | 5% | Realistic timing for design approval, tooling manufacture, sampling, revisions, and shipment. | Milestone-based schedule, stated assumptions, packaging plan, and contingency arrangements. | Score higher for a detailed schedule that identifies dependencies and separates trial time from manufacturing time. |
| After-Sales Support and Mold Maintenance | 5% | Availability of troubleshooting, repair, spare parts, and maintenance guidance after delivery. | Written support terms, maintenance instructions, spare-parts recommendations, and response process for issues. | Score higher when support scope, response expectations, and responsibility boundaries are clearly stated. |
| Total Evaluation Weight | 100% | Use the weights as a starting point and adjust them to match the mold complexity, production risk, and project priorities. Score each criterion consistently, for example from 1 (insufficient evidence) to 5 (strong, verified evidence). |