| Product and process fit | 15% | Confirm the proposed stations cover the actual assembly sequence, components, variants, and required operations. Identify manual tasks and process assumptions. | Process flow, station layout, cycle-time breakdown, product-family matrix, and a list of customer-supplied parts or tooling. | _____ | _____ / 15 |
| Capacity and line balance | 10% | Compare the demonstrated cycle time and planned operating pattern with the factory’s required output. Check whether loading, inspection, changeover, and planned downtime are included in the capacity assumptions. | Cycle-time study, station-by-station capacity assumptions, line-balance chart, and a sample production run using representative parts. | _____ | _____ / 10 |
| Flexibility and changeover | 8% | Check compatibility with the MCB variants, component tolerances, and future product changes in scope. Review how recipes, fixtures, and tooling are selected and controlled. | Variant and tooling matrix, changeover procedure, recipe-management demonstration, and a changeover trial between representative models. | _____ | _____ / 8 |
| Assembly quality controls | 12% | Verify how the machine detects missing, misoriented, or incorrectly assembled parts and how process parameters are monitored. Agree on defect definitions and acceptance limits before testing. | Control plan, inspection method descriptions, error-proofing list, sample defect challenge results, and agreed quality acceptance criteria. | _____ | _____ / 12 |
| Factory and acceptance testing | 10% | Define Factory Acceptance Testing (FAT) and Site Acceptance Testing (SAT) in advance. Use agreed samples, operating conditions, test duration, data collection, and pass/fail criteria. | Draft FAT/SAT protocols, test-piece requirements, measurement methods, issue log, and a sample completed test report. | _____ | _____ / 10 |
| Traceability and data access | 8% | Establish what production and quality data are recorded, how rejects and alarms are logged, and how records can be exported. Confirm interfaces and data ownership. | Sample production record, data-point list, export demonstration, interface specification, and data-retention and access terms. | _____ | _____ / 8 |
| Machine safety and compliance | 10% | Review risk assessment, guarding, access points, emergency stops, safety-related controls, electrical documentation, and applicable local legal requirements. Confirm responsibilities for conformity assessment. | Risk assessment, safety-function documentation, electrical schematics, applicable standards and compliance plan, and safety validation records where available. | _____ | _____ / 10 |
| Factory integration | 7% | Check footprint, utilities, material flow, upstream and downstream interfaces, controls connectivity, and site constraints. Clarify which party supplies each interface and connection. | Layout and utility requirements, interface list, signal or network specification, and a site-readiness checklist. | _____ | _____ / 7 |
| Installation and commissioning | 7% | Agree on installation scope, schedule, required site resources, commissioning activities, and the process for resolving open issues before handover. | Installation plan, responsibility matrix, commissioning checklist, handover criteria, and a defined escalation route for schedule or technical issues. | _____ | _____ / 7 |
| Training and documentation | 4% | Confirm that operators, maintenance staff, and engineers receive role-appropriate training and usable documentation in the required language. | Training agenda, operating and maintenance manuals, spare-parts list, troubleshooting guide, and electrical and mechanical drawings. | _____ | _____ / 4 |
| Ongoing service and spare parts | 5% | Review service channels, support hours, response and escalation commitments, remote-support arrangements, spare-parts availability, and warranty terms. | Written service-level terms, warranty scope, recommended critical-spares list, parts lead-time information, and support contact process. | _____ | _____ / 5 |
| Total cost and commercial clarity | 4% | Compare the full project scope, including tooling, installation, training, software or licenses, spares, and stated exclusions. Consider expected maintenance and operating costs over the planned service life. | Itemized quotation, scope and exclusions, payment milestones, warranty details, and a lifecycle-cost estimate with stated assumptions. | _____ | _____ / 4 |
| Total weighted score | Compare suppliers only after confirming that the proposed scope and test assumptions are equivalent. | Maximum possible result: 100 points. | — | _____ / 100 |