| 1 | Parent Roll Production Capacity | 20% | Published mill capacity, machine count, annual reports, and official production disclosures. | Manufacturers are compared by verified annual tissue capacity and the ability to supply jumbo parent rolls consistently. | Large, stable capacity supports continuity of supply and large-volume converting programs. |
| 2 | Product Range | 12% | Technical data sheets covering virgin, recycled, hybrid, facial, toilet, towel, napkin, and specialty tissue grades. | The range is assessed by basis weight, softness, strength, absorbency, color, and intended end use. | A broader grade portfolio enables buyers to source multiple applications from one qualified supplier. |
| 3 | Fiber Sourcing and Traceability | 12% | Chain-of-custody certificates, recycled-fiber declarations, supplier policies, and published sourcing procedures. | Higher scores are assigned where fiber origin, recycled content, and chain-of-custody documentation are independently verifiable. | Traceability helps buyers manage responsible sourcing, regulatory, and customer requirements. |
| 4 | Quality Management | 12% | ISO 9001 certification, laboratory testing procedures, product specifications, and quality-control statements. | Comparison focuses on documented quality systems, testing frequency, roll consistency, and complaint-control procedures. | Consistent basis weight, moisture, caliper, tensile strength, and softness reduce converting problems. |
| 5 | Environmental Performance | 12% | ISO 14001 or equivalent systems, environmental reports, water and energy targets, and emissions disclosures. | Publicly reported resource-efficiency targets and independently certified systems receive stronger scores. | Pulp and paper production are resource-intensive, so efficiency and emissions management affect total impact. |
| 6 | Manufacturing Footprint | 10% | Public mill locations, export markets, regional warehouses, and disclosed logistics capabilities. | Manufacturers are compared by geographic coverage and proximity to major converting and consumption markets. | A diversified footprint can shorten lead times and reduce dependence on a single production site. |
| 7 | Technical Customization | 8% | Available jumbo-roll widths, diameters, core options, basis-weight ranges, and private specification support. | Scores reflect the number of configurable parameters supported without compromising product consistency. | Correct roll dimensions and performance specifications improve machine efficiency for converters. |
| 8 | Food, Hygiene, and Safety Compliance | 6% | Product-contact declarations, hygiene-management systems, applicable test reports, and regulatory statements. | The review checks whether compliance documentation is current, product-specific, and suitable for the target market. | Documented safety controls are essential for tissue used in personal care, food-service, and institutional applications. |
| 9 | Export and Supply Reliability | 5% | Export-market information, delivery policies, packaging specifications, and publicly documented customer-service capabilities. | Comparison considers international shipping experience, order flexibility, packaging protection, and continuity planning. | Reliable delivery protects converter production schedules and reduces emergency purchasing. |
| 10 | Transparency and Market Reputation | 3% | Corporate reports, certification databases, technical publications, trade-association records, and independently verifiable disclosures. | Only claims supported by current, publicly accessible evidence are included in the comparison. | Transparent information makes supplier qualification and ongoing risk assessment more reliable. |